East of Everest
  • Home
  • Scripture Commentary & Exposition
  • Essays & Articles
  • Select Quotations
  • Indexes
    • Category Index
    • Subject Index
    • Posts & Articles Arranged by Books of the Bible
    • Scripture References Index
    • Notes & Commentary Index
    • Glossary
  • About
    • A Brief Introduction
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use & Disclaimer
    • Subscribe
  • नेपाली
  • Home
  • Scripture Commentary & Exposition
  • Essays & Articles
  • Select Quotations
  • Indexes
    • Category Index
    • Subject Index
    • Posts & Articles Arranged by Books of the Bible
    • Scripture References Index
    • Notes & Commentary Index
    • Glossary
  • About
    • A Brief Introduction
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use & Disclaimer
    • Subscribe
  • नेपाली
Topics
Abrahamic Covenant Belief & Unbelief Covenant Creation Mandate Creator & Creature Doctrine of Scripture Ethics Fact & Meaning Garden & Wilderness Gospel Ministry Hidden & Revealed Hinduism & Indian Philosophy Honor & Shame Hope Identity Image & Idolatry Incarnation Irony Judgement Justice & Judgement Knowledge & Knowing Love Marriage & Family Missions New Creation Parables Politics & Government Power Preaching & Proclamation Priesthood Reading, Writing, & Interpretation Redemptive History Resurrection Sin Sinai Covenant Society & Culture Speech & Language Tabernacle & Temple The Church The Gospel The Holy Spirit Time Virtue Word & Deed Worship
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
Subscribe
East of Everest
East of Everest
  • Home
  • Scripture Commentary & Exposition
  • Essays & Articles
  • Select Quotations
  • Indexes
    • Category Index
    • Subject Index
    • Posts & Articles Arranged by Books of the Bible
    • Scripture References Index
    • Notes & Commentary Index
    • Glossary
  • About
    • A Brief Introduction
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use & Disclaimer
    • Subscribe
  • नेपाली
  • Commentary & Exposition

No Such Thing as Christian Karma

Catastrophe & corresponding guilt
  • rah
  • April 23, 2020
“The Fall of the tower of Siloam” by David Martin
Total
0
Shares
0
0
0
0
0

Luke's Gospel, Luke 13:1-5

Post last updated on April 24, 2022

 Image:  Pitts Theology Library, Emory University

Some in Jerusalem hurried to tell the news they had heard. (Apparently, nothing is quite so titillating as another man’s judgement.) When some of these same approached our Lord and repeated the sensational rumors, Jesus did not deny their fantastic reports: Pilate had killed some unnumbered many Galileans, and then mixed their blood with sacrificial offerings. Jesus’ answer to them certainly elicited surprise, for he answered them rather differently than they expected; but this is no surprise to readers of the gospels. No one spoke like him.

Their surprise was just this: The Lord swiftly denied their obvious intimations, that tragedy had befallen the Galileans because of their wickedness. These in Jerusalem—heralds of a sort—had mistaken a tragic incident for God’s judgement, a relatively easy feat for the self-righteous. Of course, neither did the Lord deny a judgement; still, he would not allow the easy and superficial sentence of fellow men. There would be no necessary correlation between personal sin and present circumstance. There would be no such thing as Christian karma.

The meaning of the short passage is plain enough. Tragic circumstances are no certain evidence of God’s wrath, even though eventual judgment remains certain. Indeed, the Galileans who fell to Pilate were sinners, but not any more so than those who brought the news to Jesus. But never mind the Galileans; did Jesus’ audience not remember the collapse of the tower in Siloam? After all, that had happened in Jerusalem. Were the eighteen that died on that day more sinful than all those in Jerusalem who remained living? The answer is, of course, no. Circumstances and tragedies alone would not be evidence of God’s disapproval or judgement. And more to the point: Jesus would not let a truth become the basis of a lie. There is, in fact, judgement; but it does not only befall those whom most men suspect—a distant and despised other.

Some have observed that the gospels reveal a rivalry between the Galileans and those in Jerusalem. This is most evident in the contrast of the Lord and his disciples with the high priest and his allies. Here, too, that rivalry between Galilee and Jerusalem seems rather obvious. The Galileans are the “they” to those in Jerusalem, just as the residents in Jerusalem would be the “others” to the Galileans; and yet, they are all “ye” to the Lord. If men and peoples remain distinct and different in some ways, we are all guilty together. Jews and Gentiles, male and female, bond and free—and here, Galileans and those in Jerusalem: all are such in need of repentance. It was the one man able to say “ye” to all who became the savior of the believer.

Luke’s gospel recalls a day, now long ago, when an excited crowd surrounded Jesus, and brought to him news of Pilate’s murder of sinners in faraway Galilee. More salacious still was that Jesus, the innocent Galilean, would soon be crucified in Jerusalem by the same Pilate—and then rise from the dead. Christians, now, are heralds of that news, so that all might repent, whether “here” or “there.”

Share
Tweet
Pin it
Related Topics
  • Judgement
Next Article
  • Select Quotations

Compassion & Courage of the Right Kind

  • rah
  • April 29, 2020
Read the Post
You May Also Like
Read the Post
  • Commentary & Exposition
    • Acts of the Apostles
    • Acts 2:1-13

Reading the Old Testament by the New (& the New by the Old)

The Christian reads as did the prophets, by the Spirt and in search of Jesus Christ
  • rah
  • March 3, 2023
Read the Post
  • Notes on Scripture

The Jewish Feasts

The formal recognition of the life of men & the presence of God
  • rah
  • February 15, 2023
Read the Post
  • Commentary & Exposition
    • Acts of the Apostles
    • Acts 2:1-13

When Facts are Crowned with Meaning

A short introduction to the second chapter of Acts
  • rah
  • January 14, 2023
Read the Post
  • Commentary & Exposition
    • James
    • James 1:1-27

Temptation, Patience & the Gift of God’s Time

Temptation as the ground of triumph
  • rah
  • November 7, 2022
Read the Post
  • Commentary & Exposition
    • Romans
    • Romans 1:13-21

The Power of God Conceived in his Revelation to Man

The gospel, God's rule, and righteousness
  • rah
  • July 6, 2022
Read the Post
  • Notes on Scripture
    • Galatians
    • Galatians 5:1

Mood, Medium, & Message

The character of the biblical revelation informs the content of the sermon
  • rah
  • April 12, 2022
Read the Post
  • Commentary & Exposition
    • Acts of the Apostles
    • Acts 26:1-18

The Gospel & Corresponding Christian Witness

The facts of the gospel shape an ironic ministry
  • rah
  • February 23, 2022
Read the Post
  • Commentary & Exposition
    • Genesis
    • Genesis 18

Word & Deed on the Plane of Time

A field in Canaan confirms the character of God & man
  • rah
  • February 1, 2022
East of Everest
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms
  • Contact
  • Subscribe

An irregular record of occasional thoughts on scripture, religion, and culture

Copyright © 2023. All rights reserved.

Input your search keywords and press Enter.